Wholesale, Non-Agency, Workflow, Servicing, QC Audit Tools; Lender M&A Continues; CPI Helping Rates?

The folks here in Austin are sarcastically asking, “Who’s in your wallet?” Hopefully not Jennifer Garner or Samuel L. Jackson. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB… which always has our backs, right?), sued Capital One, N.A., and its parent holding company, Capital One Financial Corp., for “cheating millions of consumers out of more than $2 billion in interest.” “The CFPB alleges that Capital One promised consumers that its flagship ‘360 Savings’ account provided one of the nation’s ‘best’ and ‘highest’ interest rates, but the bank froze the interest rate at a low level while rates rose nationwide. At least IMBs and brokers don’t have to worry about running afoul of that kind of thing. Instead, many lenders here in Texas, and around the nation, are wondering who, or what, is going to bring the FHA into a new century: streamline refis that include escrows, SFR construction loans, having the monthly MI drop if the LTV drops to 75 percent (or after 7.5 years), and answering the question, “If loan quality is higher now than in 2008, why are the LLPAs the same and not diminished?” (Today’s podcast can be found here and this week’s is sponsored by Calque. White-labeled buy-before-you-sell solutions powered by Calque help you increase purchase volume and increase realtor business by helping them differentiate with a better process. With coverage in the 48 contiguous states, what are you waiting for? Hear an interview with Calque’s Michael Bremer and Ruoff’s Clint Morgan on vendor management, product expansion, and what tech offerings to look forward to this year.)

If You Needed Proof That Inflation Data is Back in Fashion…

On December 18th, one of the most striking takeaways from Fed Chair Powell’s press conference was the shift in the Fed’s focus from the labor market to inflation data. Said shift was frequently reinforced in subsequent speeches by other Fed members. Traders were left to decide how much they would shift their own playbooks–something that was especially difficult after last week’s big jobs report.  Today’s CPI was arguably less of a departure from forecasts than the jobs report, but the market reaction has been much more pronounced (in a good way).

By focusing solely on 10yr yields, the reaction is just a bit overstated, relative to the jobs report.  If we bring 2yr Treasuries into the mix, we can see that some of the discrepancy is due to curve trading.  The jobs report did more to push short term rates higher whereas the inflation data is doing more to help longer-term rates move lower.

This isn’t as simple as 2yr yields having more in common with Fed rate expectations.  Fed Funds Futures have sort of split the difference, with roughly equal reactions to each piece of data.

Why Isn’t PPI Helping Bonds This Morning?

The Producer Price Index (PPI) may not be nearly as much of a market mover as the Consumer Price Index (CPI), but it has proven capable of producing logical reactions in the past when it’s come in much higher or lower than expected. Today’s installment was much lower than expected–something that should be good for bonds. While there was a brief, initial rally, it was quickly erased and bonds returned to relatively unchanged levels.

The easiest explanation is that the market is preoccupied with CPI and there’s limited directional correlation on any given individual month.

The deeper explanation is that the PPI components that flow through to consumer inflation didn’t miss the market as much as the headline suggested.

Mortgage Rates Make a Modest Recovery Ahead of Important Inflation Data

Mortgage rates officially hit the highest levels since May 2024 yesterday, even though the average was almost imperceptibly higher than last Friday’s.  We saw a similarly small move today, but in the opposite direction. In other words, the average rate moved lower by an amount that won’t even have an impact on many of yesterday’s rate quotes. As always, keep in mind that our rate index is an average of multiple lenders and on days with very small changes, some lenders can be noticeably better or worse compared to the previous day. This morning’s economic data featured the Producer Price Index (PPI)–a report that measures inflation at the wholesale level.  It came in at lower levels than expected.  That would normally be good for rates, but it didn’t have much of an impact today.  Tomorrow’s inflation report–the Consumer Price Index (CPI)–is in a different league. If it undershoots forecasts by the same margin, rates would almost certainly move lower.  Conversely, rates would almost certainly rise if inflation overshoots forecasts. There’s no guarantee of rate-friendly data tomorrow simply because today’s inflation report was lower than expected. CPI frequently departs from PPI on any given month, even though the two tend to do the same things over longer time horizons.

Broad, Negative Momentum is Masking Normal Market Movers

Broad, Negative Momentum is Masking Normal Market Movers

Tuesday featured a much weaker PPI report that failed to inspire any lasting rally in the bond market. While there were a few ways to reconcile that specific turn of events by examining the internal components of the data, it’s also true that bond market momentum has been broadly negative recently.  At times like this, data has to work harder if it wants to push rates lower.  It can even seem like rates move higher whether the data is good or bad. Today’s recap video includes an in-depth assessment of this phenomenon. Long story short, things are still mostly logical, as long as we’re considering all the pieces on the board.

Econ Data / Events

Core PPI M/M

0.0 vs 0.3 f’cast, 0.2 prev

Core PPI Y/Y

3.5 vs 3.8 f’cast, 3.5 prev

Market Movement Recap

08:42 AM initial gains after PPI, but mostly reversed now.  MBS unchanged and 10yr down less than half a bp at 4.781

12:15 PM MBS unchanged and 10yr up 1.5bps at 4.798

03:04 PM nearly unchanged at the close.  MBS up 1 tick (.03) and 10yr unchanged at 4.783