Fed Day Selling Spree as Press Conference Trumps The Dots

Powell Press Conference Trumps The Dots, Sparking Moderate Sell-Off

Of today’s Fed events (rate announcement, dot plot, and press conference), it was the dots that were most likely to cause the biggest reaction. That proved to be the case, but only for the 30 minutes leading up to Powell’s presser.  Bonds had already begun pushing back against the rally by the time Powell started fielding questions.  Several of his responses added fuel to the fire. In not so many words, Powell said the dots don’t mean the Fed is cutting twice more in 2024 and that the Fed will instead be taking things meeting by meeting as they digest incoming econ data. While that’s very standard for the Fed playbook, it didn’t convey the level of concern for the economy (bullish for rates) that the market was priced for.  The reversal seems extreme in the short term due to the dot-driven rally, but yields closed no higher than they did last Tuesday–2 days after the jobs report rally that took rates to their lowest levels since October. 

Econ Data / Events

Building Permits (Aug)

1.312M vs 1.37M f’cast, 1.362M prev

Housing starts number mm (Aug)

1.307M vs 1.37M f’cast, 1.428M prev

Market Movement Recap

09:48 AM Modestly stronger overnight and little-changed so far this morning.  MBS up 1 tick (.03) and 10yr down half a bp at 4.027

11:34 AM Just barely weaker now.  MBS down 1 tick (.03) and 10yr up less than half a bp at 4.035

02:06 PM Stronger after the dot plot.  MBS up just over an eighth and 10yr down 3.3bps at 3.998

02:40 PM MBS now down 2 ticks (.06) on the day. 10yr yields are up 2.3bps at 4.053

02:56 PM MBS now down a quarter point on the day and 10yr up 5bps at 4.08

Mortgage Rates HIGHER (Not Lower) After Fed Rate Cut

Several things happen on Fed Day–especially on the 4 out of 8 examples with updated rate forecasts from Fed members.  The official announcement of a rate cut is typically the least important aspect.  In fact, it is usually entirely unimportant in terms of its impact on mortgage rates. Instead, the bonds that determine mortgage rates are much more likely to react to the Fed’s dot plot (the chart showing each Fed member’s rate forecast over the next few years) and the press conference with the Fed Chair. The dots are released at 2pm at the same time as the rate cut announcement.  The press conference follows at 2:30pm and usually lasts 50 minutes. This staggered timing makes for plenty of back and forth volatility on occasion and today was a prime example.  The dots helped bonds because they signaled better odds for two additional cuts in 2025 as opposed to only one.  The market was mostly expecting that, but it wasn’t fully priced-in to prevailing rates.  Things changed during Powell’s press conference and bonds ended up more than reversing the initial move. Powell framed today’s cut as a “risk management” cut and emphasized that the forecasts in the dot plot do not represent a plan for future cuts. Rather, the Fed will continue to take things on a meeting by meeting basis and make decisions based on the new data that becomes available over that time. As the underlying bond market responded, most mortgage lenders issued mid-day changes to the rates announced this morning. The net effect is that mortgage rates are most certainly HIGHER this afternoon compared to yesterday’s latest levels, not to mention this morning’s.