Three Straight Months of Improvement in Builder Confidence, But There’s a Catch

The December National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI) edged up one point to 39. This is the 3rd straight month of improvement in the index–a development that could be confused for something encouraging.  But the reality is that builder confidence is merely drifting along just barely above the lowest levels in more than a decade. This has been the case for more than 3 years now. Peeling back the layers shows familiar constraints, even if the numbers shuffled slightly. The index measuring current sales conditions rose one point to 42, while the gauge tracking prospective buyer traffic held steady at 26—still firmly in “low to very low” territory. Future sales expectations improved one point to 52, extending a three-month stretch above breakeven. “Market conditions remain challenging with two-thirds of builders reporting they are offering incentives to move buyers off the fence,” said NAHB Chairman Buddy Hughes. “Meanwhile, builders are contending with rising material and labor prices, as tariffs are having serious repercussions on construction costs.” Pricing pressure continues to do much of the heavy lifting. NAHB reports that 40% of builders cut home prices in December, marking the second consecutive month at or above that level. The average price reduction eased to 5%, down from 6% in November, while the use of sales incentives climbed to 67%—the highest share in the post-Covid period. Regionally, the three-month moving averages show a broad-based but still uneven improvement. The Northeast slipped to 47, while the Midwest strengthened to 43. The South rose to 36 and the West improved to 34, though both regions remain more acutely exposed to affordability pressures.

Mortgage Apps Still Strong vs Last Year, But Down Slightly Last Week

Seasonally adjusted mortgage application activity declined 3.8% last week, according to MBA’s Weekly Mortgage Applications Survey for the week ending December 12. Unadjusted applications fell 5% from the prior week, reflecting a typical seasonal slowdown as the year draws to a close. The Refinance Index slipped 4% from the previous week but remains 86% higher than the same week one year ago, underscoring continued refinance interest as rates remain rangebound. Purchase activity also softened, with the seasonally adjusted Purchase Index down 3% from the prior week. On an unadjusted basis, purchase applications declined 7% week-over-week but are still running 13% above last year’s pace. “Mortgage rates inched up last week following the FOMC meeting, as investors interpreted the comments to signal that we are near the end of this rate cutting cycle. As a result, mortgage applications declined slightly,” said Mike Fratantoni, MBA’s SVP and Chief Economist. “Purchase application volume typically drops off quickly at the end of the year, and this shifts the mix of the business, with the refinance share reaching 59 percent last week, the highest level since September. However, refinance activity has remained mostly the same for the past month as rates continue to hold at around the same narrow range.” The refinance share of applications increased to 59.0% from 58.2% the previous week. ARM share rose to 7.2%. FHA share edged lower to 19.5%, while VA share increased to 16.6%. USDA share increased to 0.4%.

Limited Follow-Through After Shockingly Big Miss

Limited Follow-Through After Shockingly Big Miss

If you told the average trader that today’s core CPI would come in at 2.6% vs 3.0% year over year, they would have expected a much bigger reaction than we saw today. Ironically, the size of the miss may be one of those reasons. It’s so far outside the realm of expected possibilities that traders immediately assumed the presence of legitimate issues with November’s data collection. Nonetheless, it was worth a moderate extension of the overnight rally.

Econ Data / Events

Continued Claims (Dec)/06

1,897K vs 1930K f’cast, 1838K prev

Jobless Claims (Dec)/13

224K vs 225K f’cast, 236K prev

Philly Fed Business Index (Dec)

-10.2 vs 3 f’cast, -1.7 prev

Philly Fed Prices Paid (Dec)

43.60 vs — f’cast, 56.10 prev

y/y CORE CPI (Nov)

2.6% vs 3% f’cast, 3.0% prev

y/y Headline CPI (Nov)

2.7% vs 3.1% f’cast, 3.0% prev

Market Movement Recap

08:47 AM Rallying after CPI data. MBS up a quarter point and 10yr down 4.4bps at 4.115

12:18 PM Off best levels. MBS still up 5 ticks (.16) and 10yr down 3.1bps at 4.127

02:56 PM MBS up 7 ticks (.22) and 10yr down 4.2bps at 4.117

Mortgage Rates Near Lowest Levels Since October

Officially, there were 2 days at the end of November where the average lender’s 30yr fixed rates were just a hair lower (0.02% difference).  Otherwise, today’s rates would be the lowest since late October. The improvement follows this morning’s release of November’s Consumer Price Index (CPI). Inflation was so far below expectations that it raised new questions about just how much the government shutdown impacted data collection. The market still treated it as good news for rates, but most of the improvement was already in place before the data came out. CPI marked the last of 2025’s top tier economic reports when it comes to potential impacts on rates. This doesn’t mean rates won’t move between now and January–only that they’re far less likely to make any big changes based on economic reports.

Jumbo, Hedging, HELOC, Custom Newsletter Products; STRATMOR the UWM/TWO Deal

Lender and Broker Services, Products, and Software “The federal quality control standards under Dodd Frank for automated valuation models (AVMs) require valuation professionals to provide greater transparency in how AVMs determine credible, consistent, and objective property values. That’s why it’s important (and required) to regularly test, monitor and validate your AVMs. ICE’s advanced AVMs and self-service valuation reporting tool deliver unmatched transparency into ICE’s rigorous testing methodologies to validate output performance, coverage and accuracy of our AVMs, helping clients stay aligned with new and evolving regulatory guidelines. Read our latest blog to learn how ICE’s solutions can help enhance valuation accuracy, reduce valuation bias, and strengthen regulatory compliance.” Most lender newsletters still open with “Dear [First Name],” and today’s tech-savvy borrowers know exactly what comes next: generic spam. In a retention-driven market, this predictable approach lowers engagement and actively erodes the LOs reputation as a trusted advisor. CANDID introduces the industry’s first 1:1 newsletter engine, replacing static merge fields with generative AI that writes a completely unique message for every contact. By synthesizing borrower data, social activity, and local market news, the platform drafts thousands of distinct, hyper-relevant emails in minutes. This allows marketing executives to scale high-touch personalization without requiring a single additional minute of manual effort. Stop sending generic, nationwide newsletters that get ignored and start automating the personal touch that drives referrals. See CANDID in action here.